multiple offers

Is the housing market starting to slow?

June 8, 2021 By Ryan Lundquist 36 Comments

Is this crazy housing market slowing? Let’s talk about that today. On one hand stats are basically at all-time highs, but when we look deeper we’re starting to see some subtle signs of slowing. What are you seeing out there?

QUICK SUMMARY: The market is still bananas, but we’re seeing some slight slowing. Stats could change in coming weeks and months, but for now the best available information suggests a slightly slower trend. And I’m not saying the market is dull, so save your hate mail. It’s more like housing was driving 135 mph and now it’s driving 127 mph.

Some subtle examples of slowing:

1) It’s taking slightly longer to sell: It May it took only six days to sell (median) in the Sacramento region while pendings over the past four weeks took seven days to get into contract (median).

2) Fewer multiple offers: In May we saw the number of multiple offers slough by 6% as seen in the graph below. We are still basically at all-time high levels, but the percentage of multiple offers is slightly lower than it was.

3) Buyers paid slightly less above asking: In May buyers paid an average of $20,975 above asking price while in April they paid $22,247. This is a very minor difference that I’m honestly hesitant to talk about because we’ll have to revise May stats in a few weeks once more sales get added into MLS. So it’s possible this stat in May could change. Though right now the best available market stats show buyers paid slightly less above contract price in May compared to April.

4) Lower sales to original list price ratio: In May buyers paid an average of 103.3% above the original list price compared to 103.8% in April. Okay, this is even closer than the example in number three, so again, I’m reluctant to post this – especially since we’ll need to refresh this number when more May sales are counted. But for now it’s something to watch. Keep in mind the number in April at nearly 104% was literally the highest amount ever above the original list price, so 103.3% is telling of an incredibly competitive market.

5) Word on the street: I’m hearing from real estate agents that they’re seeing slightly fewer offers and having slightly fewer showings. This is mostly anecdotal and of course subjective to whatever sliver of the market an agent is working, but it’s something to consider.

CLOSING ADVICE:

a) Know the seasonal market: Each year around this time in a normal year we start to see the real estate market slow and this image shows some of the things we can watch. Remember, prices could keep going up in coming time, but prices reflect pending contracts from the past, so being on the cutting edge of the trend in a market has more to do with watching other stuff before the trend eventually catches up to prices.

UPDATE: I just wanted to say I fully expect prices to increase in June and who knows how much longer. We are definitely still in an increasing market to say the least. I know it seems ludicrous to be talking about slowing in the midst of such insane competition. But this is exactly the conversation to have because let’s watch all the little things instead of getting overly distracted by the bling of sexy price stats. Know what I’m saying?

b) Don’t misread this post: The market is still 100% on steroids, so I’m hoping people don’t walk away thinking, “Ryan said the market was dull.” Nope. Also, the market is not crashing, so be cautious about painting what looks like normal seasonal slowing with a doom and gloom brush. Buyers, you’re still going to have to make aggressive offers. But sellers, stay in touch because even though you have an incredible amount of power, you did lose just a little recently.

c) The x-factor of mortgage rates: If mortgage rates dip below 3% again it could easily change the speed and trajectory of the market.

d) Be careful of rose-colored lenses: It’s easy in real estate to only speak in ultra positive terms about the housing market. But markets change temperature all the time and we have to be real about the trends because buyers and sellers need good advice for the market that actually exists. My advice? Let the stats form your perspective and narrative. Don’t get trapped into thinking you need to speak in hyper-positive language either to be successful in real estate.

e) Say something different if the temperature changes: If the market speeds up in coming months and we don’t end up seeing seasonal slowing, then that’s what we need to say. The best we can do at any given moment is interpret the stats in front of us and let that shape what we say. So for now it looks like we’re seeing some slowing. What does the future hold? We’ll see.

MARKET STATS: I’ll have lots of market stats out this week on my social channels, so watch Twitter, Instagram, LinkedIn, and Facebook.

APRIL TO MAY: How has the market changed recently? Take a look at the April to May visuals below.

Prices in Placer tend to bounce around month to month because there aren’t that many sales. Take these with a grain of salt.

NOTE ON PRICE GROWTH: Last year the market was dull at the beginning of the pandemic and there was a slump in sales and even prices – which tends to inflate the numbers this year. My advice? Take the percentages with a grain of salt. I think it’s likely better to focus on price metrics generally being up about 20-23% or so rather than fixating on pandemic percentages at 25-30%.

Thanks for being here.

SHARING POLICY: You can share my stats and visuals above, but please attribute the source. Here are 6 ways to share my content (not copy verbatim).

Questions: Are you seeing any slowing at all? What is the market like in the trenches right now? I’d love to hear your take.

If you liked this post, subscribe by email (or RSS). Thanks for being here.

How much are buyers paying above the list price?

December 1, 2020 By Ryan Lundquist 14 Comments

It’s exhausting being a buyer because it’s so easy to get outbid. It seems like finding a house is a bit like trying to buy the new PlayStation 5. Let’s talk about that today. How much are buyers actually paying above the list price? And if you’re not local, what are you seeing in your area?

A spring market in the fall: First, here is a big market update I did for SAFE Credit Union (40 minutes). Enjoy below (or here).

QUICK SUMMARY:

There isn’t just one amount buyers pay above the list price
The market isn’t the same in every price range.
We’ve seen huge growth this year between $10-20K
About 80% of sales are somewhere between below list and $20K
Not everything is getting bid up
About 40% of sales sold at list price or below last month
2/3 of the million dollar market sells at list or below
Higher prices tend to pay more above list (when above list happens)
Only 3.5% of sales went $50K+ above the list price last month
Look to the comps. Don’t just blindly offer above the list price.

SKIM OR READ IN DEPTH:

How much are buyers paying above the list price? Here are some brand new visuals to show how much buyers are paying above the list price. These might take a minute to digest. This image basically shows the total percentage of sales in the market. For instance, in the visual below 31.4% of homes last month sold below the list price, 9.9% of sales sold at the list price, etc…

Under $400K:

Between $500-750K:

Million dollar market:

This visual compares last year with this year.

Here’s the same information but with numbers. Do you like this better?

HOW MUCH ARE BUYERS PAYING ABOVE LIST PRICE?

1) Mixed results: There isn’t just one answer that applies to every price range and escrow.

2) The biggest change: In many cases buyers are tending to pay ten to twenty thousand over the original list price to secure a contract. About one in five buyers paid $10-20K over the list price last month. In some cases prices get bid up even more, but close to eight out of ten sales are somewhere between below the list price and twenty thousand above the list price. Keep in mind many buyers are getting a loan for the full contract price, so paying above the list price doesn’t always mean buyers are bringing that much cash to the table.

3) Not everything gets bid up: It might be surprising, but this month we saw about one in three sales sell below the list price. It just goes to show sellers have to price it right – even in this wonky market. We also have to be careful about saying “EVERYTHING IS GETTING BID UP” when that’s not true.

4) Million dollar market: The highest prices basically show if buyers are paying above the list price it tends to be more significant. But two thirds of all million dollar sales last month sold at either the list price or below the list price, so the bulk of homes in this range aren’t getting bid up like the rest of the market. Like I’ve said before, this is the most overpriced segment of the market.

5) Not sensational: Only 3.5% of all sales went fifty thousand over the list price last month, so let’s be careful about shining a spotlight on this tiny sliver and saying, “Everything is getting bid up $50-100K.” Nope.

6) Don’t offer above without looking at comps: Buyers, be prepared to offer above the list price, but don’t blindly offer $10-20K above without really considering the comps and advice from your agent. Remember, the market isn’t the same at every price range either.

7) Appraisers: These days appraisers are getting huge flack for “coming in low.” Look, sometimes appraisers are legitimately missing the mark, but other times properties are getting into contract way beyond what is reasonable, so the appraisal should come in “low”. Sellers, sometimes the highest offer isn’t always the best one if there is going to be an appraisal involved. And to my appraiser colleagues, our role is never to “hit the number”, but let’s be sure to account for the true temperature of the market in our reports.

Anyway, I hope that was helpful.

Questions: What stands out to you most above? What is it like right now in the trenches for buyers? Anything stories to share? Did I miss something?

If you liked this post, subscribe by email (or RSS). Thanks for being here.

Horses aren’t allowed & a big market update

January 14, 2020 By Ryan Lundquist 19 Comments

The other day a client asked me to include a statement in my appraisal that horses are allowed on the property. It was a huge lot, so it seemed like that might be okay… But I said NO for a very specific reason. Let’s talk about this and then for those interested let’s take a deep look at the local market.

A conversation with the city:

Me: Are horses allowed in the Tahoe Park neighborhood?

City: No. You need agricultural zoning for that to work. City of Sacramento code says: “It’s unlawful to keep, harbor, or maintain any bovine animal, horse, etc… on any parcel located in the city.” There are some locations that will work in the northern part of the city due to agricultural zoning, but not this location.

Me: What if it’s a really large lot though?

City: No. You need agricultural zoning.

Me: What if it’s an emotional support horse? (I wish I asked)

The point: On paper it might look like a horse property, but what does zoning allow? That’s the question. This is a good reminder to call the city or county to verify what is legally possible. To be fair owners can sometimes obtain a variance, but otherwise horses weren’t going to fly in this tract subdivision.

Class I’m teaching on Jan 16th: I’m doing a big market update at SAR from 9-10:30am. We’ll talk through the market, tips for talking to clients, and ideas for where to focus business. I’d love to see you there. Sign up here.

Any thoughts?

—–——– Big local market update (long on purpose) —–——–

This post is designed to skim or digest slowly.

A QUICK LOOK AT CONTENT

Recap of 2019
Loans & cash over the past decade
The number of sales in 2019 vs 2018
Distressed sales in Sacramento County
Sales above $1M over the past eight years
Sales below $100K over the past eight years
Sales volume “recovery”
Not a crash, but on the lower side
Price growth is slowing down
Comparing last year vs this year
Price Cycles
Housing supply is anemic
More visuals for surrounding counties

Scroll down to see what captures your interest. There are a number of new visuals too. I used a different format. What do you think?

DOWNLOAD 145 visuals: Please download all graphs here as a zip file. See my sharing policy for 5 ways to share (please don’t copy verbatim).

1) Recap of 2019: The year ended up feeling somewhat normal after a painfully dull last half of 2018 that left us wondering what would happen in 2019. Price gains were modest, there were slightly fewer sales compared to the prior year, and it typically took several days longer to sell in most counties (besides El Dorado taking over ten days longer). Here are some trends to watch in 2020.

2) Loans & cash over the past decade: These visuals are brand new and I hope you like them. Conventional financing has taken off this past decade, right? FHA used to be more common until conventional products began offering lower down payments. There was actually an uptick in FHA though this year, so let’s keep watching that. Cash sales are not a big factor in today’s market despite sellers thinking they are.

3) The number of sales in 2019 vs 2018: There were more sales at higher prices and less at lower prices. This makes sense for a market that showed upward price movement.

4) Distressed sales in Sacramento County: It’s astounding to think that 84% of sales in Sacramento County were distressed in early 2009, whereas now we have fewer than 1.5% bank-owned sales and 0.5% short sales. People keep asking me if we’re poised to see these numbers start increasing again. Technically there’s really no place to go but up since distressed sales have bottomed out. But I wouldn’t expect these to increase dramatically because there’s no mechanism in place right now that would trigger mass-distressed sales. There is not the ticking time-bomb of adjustable rate mortgages or an economic collapse. But if we had a devastating economic downturn or some other huge issue, that could change things. There are definitely voices that talk about a coming “wave” of distressed properties, but this wave has not materialized despite prophecies for many years. Granted, bank-owned sales are up very slightly this year, but it’s not statistically significant. I’ll keep you posted with any changes.

5) Sales above $1M over the past eight years: This is a fascinating way to look at the market. I know there are many colors, but here is the number of sales above $1M for each respective year. What’s the trend?

6) Sales below $100K over the past eight years: On the other side of the price spectrum, here are sales below $100K. There aren’t too many these days. I know, everyone wants to go back to 2012. But the problem is financing was hardly available back then to so many people who had a foreclosure or short sale on their record. So even though prices were right so to speak, financing wasn’t.

7) Sales volume “recovery”: We’ve begun to see sales volume come out of a funk as it was down for over a year. However, there’s an asterisk to this news because we’ve seen sexier volume over the past few months, but we’re also comparing these recent months to a REALLY dull season last year. So of course the numbers today look better. My advice? Take this news with a grain of salt and save rejoicing for the spring season if we see this trend continue.

8) Not a crash, but on the lower side: As I said above, we’ve been having a definitive sales volume slump since mid-2018, but lately volume has been stronger. The number of sales this year has basically been down about 3% or so from last year in the region, though when looking at the past five years we can see volume is down closer to 5% or so. But here’s the thing. Sales volume this year was still on the lower side of normal (and even higher than 2014 which was a dull year). This is a good reminder to look at stats in a wider context instead of having tunnel vision stuck on one or two years. For reference, when the market crashed in 2005 we saw a 40% drop in sales volume over one year.

9) Price growth is slowing down: Price growth has been slowing, which basically means prices aren’t rising as quickly as they used to. Though technically the monthly and quarterly data below show higher price growth this year. Does that mean the market has been more aggressive? Has it begun to rebound? Not necessarily. I recommend being hesitant about sharing this positive-sounding news because the market was REALLY dull last year. Thus when we compare monthly and quarterly numbers today with dismal stats from 2018 it can really inflate the figures.

10) Comparing last year vs this year: All year long most price metrics have been up about 2-4% each month compared to last year, but these past three months they’ve been higher. This is likely due to stats sagging last year during a dull 2018 fall season. I know, I keep mentioning that. Additionally, mortgage rates went down a few months ago and we’re likely seeing some of the effect of that.

11) Price Cycles: Markets go up and down. That’s just what they do. Here’s a look at the past few price cycles in various counties. This is a fascinating way to see the market. Do you see the price deceleration in this current cycle? Also, in El Dorado County I pulled my stats just two days ago and the median price was down 0.1% instead of at 0% in my recap image above (that’s why the numbers are slightly different).

12) Housing supply is anemic: There isn’t much on the market right now, so buyers are hungry for good product. Remember, the spring market usually comes alive in the sales stats by March, but this means the market really started to move in January and February when these sales from March got into contract. Anyway, inventory looks to be mirroring what we saw a few years prior to last year’s dull season as you can see in the image directly below. There should be more homes hitting the market in coming months if we have a normal seasonal rhythm. Sellers, there’s nothing wrong with listing in January or February either. If you sense demand is there and especially if rates go down, you’ll have a captive audience.

13) More visuals: I know, there are too many visuals already. But here’s more. I never post them all either, so check out the download if you wish.

SACRAMENTO REGION (more graphs here):

SACRAMENTO COUNTY (more graphs here):

PLACER COUNTY (more graphs here):

EL DORADO COUNTY (more graphs here):

DOWNLOAD 145 visuals: Please download all graphs here as a zip file. See my sharing policy for 5 ways to share (please don’t copy verbatim).

Thanks for respecting my content: Please don’t copy my post verbatim or alter the images in any way. I will always show respect for your original work and give you full credit, so I ask for that same courtesy. Here are 5 ways to share my content.

Questions: What stands out to you about the market last year? What are you seeing right now? Anything to add?

If you liked this post, subscribe by email (or RSS). Thanks for being here.

Not everything is getting multiple offers

October 2, 2019 By Ryan Lundquist 14 Comments

Everything is getting multiple offers, right? Many sellers feel that way, but it’s just not true. Today let’s dive deeply into what is actually happening with multiple offers. I’m excited about this and I hope you like it too.

Non-locals: If you’re not local, would understanding more about multiple offers help you? Could you ask your MLS about including a “multiple offers” field? This is how I’ve been able to extract data like this for my market.

FIVE THINGS ABOUT MULTIPLE OFFERS

1) A rhythm of multiple offers: There is a rhythm to seeing multiple offers in the Sacramento region. There are more multiple offers in the spring and less as summer and fall unfold. This isn’t a huge surprise, but it’s cool to see on paper. If you wanted to know, 42% of sales last month had more than one offer (which is what I mean by “multiple offers”).

2) The market isn’t always hot: It’s tempting to talk about real estate like it’s always “hot”, but it’s not. Every year the market heats up and cools as you can see in the images below. But on top of a normal seasonal up and down dynamic we’re seeing price growth slow too. In other words, prices just haven’t been rising as fast as they used to. When it comes to multiple offers, we’re seeing fewer these days compared to the past couple years. This is such a good point for sellers to understand. The market isn’t what it used to be. It’s still very competitive if you’re priced right, but it’s not like it was in the heyday of 2013.

3) Sellers, you might just get one offer: It’s easy to think everything is getting multiple offers, but it’s not true. When looking at thousands of current pendings, 59% of homes have only one offer while 20% have two offers. Thus 79% of properties in contract right now have two offers or fewer. My advice? Price realistically for today and you might get a couple offers. But you might only get one. Oh, and if you overprice you likely won’t get any offers at all.

4) It’s more aggressive at lower prices: This won’t come as a shock, but we’re seeing more multiple offers at lower price points. Here’s a look at multiple offers among current pendings as well as recent sales. Keep in mind there aren’t many sales and pendings above $700,000, so I wouldn’t put too much weight on these categories showing a higher percentage.

5) Many layers to the onion: Looking at multiple offers is just one way to see what the market is doing. The truth is there are many layers of the onion when it comes to real estate data, which is why I advise looking to many different metrics to understand the market. In other words, it’s not just about multiple offers to me (but this is cool to see).

QUESTIONS:

How did I get this data? A few years ago our MLS started including fields for “multiple offers” and “number of offers”. I’ve been watching these metrics and reporting on them for the past year or so, but today I’ve taken it to the next level.

Is this data reliable? I’ve had a few people question whether this data is reliable. Of course data is only good as the input by real estate agents and hopefully the truth is being told. Do some people fudge the numbers? Probably. But keep in mind we’re looking at thousands of sales and pendings, so a few outliers won’t sway the trend. Moreover, the bulk of pendings actually show just one offer, which helps support the notion of agent honesty.

I hope this was interesting or helpful.

RECESSION PRESENTATION: I keep getting asked about home prices and a looming recession, so I put together a quick presentation to download.

BEER & HOUSING CONVERSATION: Do you want to hang out at Yolo Brewing? On Saturday October 5th from 2-5pm I’m co-hosting a get-together. Hope to see you there. Details here.

Questions: What stands out to you most about the images above? What are you seeing with multiple offers these days? I’d love to hear your take.

If you liked this post, subscribe by email (or RSS). Thanks for being here.

multiple offers

Share:

Share:

Share:

Share: