Sacramento Appraisal Blog | Real Estate Appraiser

Real estate appraisals for divorce, estate settlement, loans, property tax appeal, pre-listing and more. We cover Sacramento, Placer and Yolo County. We're professional, courteous and timely.

Placer County

Seeing the market while driving, crunching numbers, & eating tacos

By 13 Comments

It’s not just about numbers. Look, I geek out over stats, but sometimes all we need to do is drive around town or have a few conversations to see the market. Today I wanted to share some trends I’m seeing by sharing photos I’ve taken recently. Then for those interested we’ll get into the numbers in my big monthly market update below. Anyway, let’s take a drive.

The rage of modern homes: Modern units like this are popping up in Sacramento in places that are typically close to Downtown. This small development is located in Midtown.

Flipping seminars: I’ve seen this guy on late-night TV promising to teach people how to flip homes. The problem? The market isn’t actually that great for flipping in Sacramento right now. Read about celebrity flipping seminars here.

The Prince tree: A local artist in Citrus Heights paid tribute to Prince in her front yard. I know something like this would not fly in an HOA community, but it reminds us there is maybe some room for creative expression in real estate.

Marijuana homes getting busted: There was a big raid last week where federal agents targeted 75 homes in the Sacramento region that were suspected to be “grow houses”. Remember, recreational cannabis is legal in California, but it’s never legal to have a commercial grow operation in a residential property. Anyway, I came across a different article in the SacBee that listed nine addresses of previous grow houses (golden data for appraisers).

Tearing down the neighborhood: A ranch house in Arden Park was purchased for $462,000 and torn down to build a custom home (currently pending close to $1.3M). This doesn’t happen in every neighborhood, so I’m always asking questions: What is being built? Who is buying? What is being flipped? Where is the bottom of the price market? Where is the top?

Neighborhoods that are changing: This is a colorful six-unit modern project in Oak Park off 2nd Avenue. Modern units like this are starting to pop up – especially around The Broadway Triangle.  

Here’s a modern project under construction on 1st Avenue in Oak Park.

The word on the street (while eating tacos): Every few months or so I get together with a group of real estate friends to eat at Chandos (my fav taco joint). It’s not like we gather to have exclusive rigid market talk, but I always leave with some insight because our taco club has investors, a loan officer, and a Realtor / flipper. I find understanding a market is about crunching numbers, but it’s also about the word on the street. This is why I regularly ask people, “What are you seeing out there?”

I hope that was interesting or helpful. Anything to add?

And now for anyone interested in the numbers….

–——-——- Big monthly market update (it’s long on purpose) ———–——-

Spring is definitely here. Well, the market has been alive for a couple of months, but we’re now really starting to see it in the stats. The median price rose about 4% in the region last month and it’s up 9% from last year. Overall we’re seeing all the normal signs of a spring market in that it took 7 less days to sell last month, more listings are hitting the market, and sales volume is increasing for the season. Housing inventory is up slightly in the region from where it was last year and so is sales volume (though volume is down 1.5% in Sacramento County).

New recap images: I spend so much time putting together graphs, but I’ve struggled to figure out a way to quickly sum things up. Anyway, here’s a stab at a summary. Do you like these? Anything you’d change? Feedback is welcome.

A few quick things:

Not much cash actually: It’s easy to believe cash is dominating – especially from the Bay Area, but it’s really not (did you hear that sellers?). Cash sales were 15% of all sales last month in the region and in Sacramento County we actually have about 3% less cash this year so far.

Oh dang… the median price: If you didn’t know, the median price is now 6.9% lower than when the “bubble” burst in Sacramento County in 2005. I tend to see jaws drop when sharing this stat, but here are some things to keep in mind about bubble conversations. Remember, there is no formula that says our market will “pop” if we go 6.9% higher, so it’s important to not get too stuck on the previous peak. Today’s market certainly has an inflated feel, but it’s also being driven by different factors than 2005 too, so it’s not a perfect comparison to always look back to 2005. Anyway, let’s not get too side tracked, but navigating this conversation will be key in coming time for real estate professionals, and I’ve heard some sellers wanting to list too in light of how high prices are. 

Zillow is going to sell homes: Yesterday HousingWire reported Zillow is going to be selling homes. There was suspicion this would happen, but The Big Z always denied it. Well, the cat’s out of the bag and I’m wondering how this will unfold. I’m also wondering if they’re going to try to chop agent fees. Let’s talk about this more as things develop. On a side note, will we have to watch listings and sales on Zillow in addition to MLS?

I could write more, but let’s get visual instead.

DOWNLOAD 61 graphs HERE: Please download all graphs here as a zip file. See my sharing policy for 5 ways to share (please don’t copy verbatim).

SACRAMENTO COUNTY (more graphs here):

SACRAMENTO REGION (more graphs here):

PLACER COUNTY (more graphs here):

DOWNLOAD 61 graphs HERE: Please download all graphs here as a zip file. See my sharing policy for 5 ways to share (please don’t copy verbatim).

Questions: What images around town remind you of what the market is doing? I’d love to hear your take.

If you liked this post, subscribe by email (or RSS). Thanks for being here.

Slumping volume, too many million dollar listings, & rising rates

By 14 Comments

We love sensational real estate headlines, but here’s what tends to happen. We talk about something like it’s the biggest thing ever, it ends up being no big deal, and then we move on to the next thing. It sort of reminds me of Y2K because there was so much fear about worldwide chaos, but then nothing happened. All bark. No bite. Anyway, let’s talk about a few issues, and you decide if these are hyped-up “Y2K real estate trends” or not. Then I have a big Sacramento market update for anyone interested. Any thoughts?

Rising interest rates:

For years we’ve heard interest rates would rise, but nothing really happened. Well, now things have begun to change. It’s like Mom & Dad were threatening a punishment, but they never followed through, so we didn’t believe them…. until now. Interest rates are finally ticking up and it’s bound to make an impact on prices if the increase hits buyers in the wallet. What I mean is if buyers in mass can afford the increase, then it’s not a big deal unless buyers start showing resistance. An increase in rates won’t hit everyone the same either as buyers at the lowest price ranges will feel it the most. Keep in mind rising rates in the near future could actually lead to buyers rushing the market instead of withdrawing from it. What will happen? Nobody knows. Heck, rates are still incredibly low, and we don’t even know if they’ll continue to rise. But the Fed has been more forthright about coming rate hikes, so that’s why this feels like more than pure hype. Anyway, let’s see how this plays out and keep an eye on creative financing from lenders too.

Are there too many million dollar listings?

Headlines are talking about the high-end market softening in portions of the country. Locally I’ve heard that sentiment since inventory seems imbalanced at the top right now in the Sacramento region. It sounds alarming to think there is a year’s worth of million dollar listings, so it’s easy to conclude the high-end market is sagging. But last year at the same time we saw nearly the same number of listings. If you need to see the numbers, at the beginning of February 2017 there were 213 listings above $1M and this year there were 220 listings at the beginning of the month. It would be insanity to see twelve months of housing inventory at the lowest prices, but it’s actually fairly normal for January stats for the high-end. In short, it could be possible the million dollar market is softening, but for now let’s not use the number of listings alone as evidence.

Is sales volume slumping?

I’ve been noticing real estate headlines talking about slumping sales volume in many markets across the United States. For Sacramento County we actually had the strongest January since 2013, yet it is true that yearly volume is down 2.5%. This isn’t shocking news because nearly all of last year volume was down 1-2% depending on the month. Here’s the thing though. Sales volume in 2017 was slightly lower than 2016, but it was actually higher than 2015. This reminds us if we only look at one year of sales we might miss the bigger trend. Anyway, volume is also down in the entire region, though only by 1%. Overall it’s fair to talk about lower volume because that’s a fact, but it’s probably not fair to hype the issue too much – especially since volume is actually higher than 2015. Let’s keep watching though because it would be a huge deal if sales volume really did start to decline significantly.

Overpricing because the market is so “hot”:

In case you wanted some background noise while working, I did a Facebook Live Q&A last week with Realtor Justin Vierra and we talked about pricing for the “unicorn.” Overpricing is a real issue in today’s market. By the way, if anyone wants to do podcasts and interviews, I love that stuff. You can listen to our hour-long conversation here too in case you wanted more than just this clip.

I hope that was interesting. Anything to add?

–——-——- Big monthly market update (it’s long on purpose) ———–——-

Right now we’re in that weird place where sales stats are sagging from a slower fall season, but the market is heating up. For January stats we saw all the typical signs we’d expect to see. Sales volume declined, it took an extra day to sell, most price metrics sloughed, and inventory increased. The median price in Sacramento County actually has been fairly flat, but last week I talked about how the market really did slow down despite the flatness. Anyway, I have quite a few visuals below to help show how the market has moved in recent time.

Housing supply: Inventory is up a bit right now. It’s not much, but this January was up 6.5% in the region compared to last year at the same time. Over the past few months inventory has actually ticked up slightly, and that’s welcome news for the market. Yet before writing home to say the housing shortage is over (it’s not), let’s wait to see what happens during the spring market. I’m not overly impressed at a few months of slightly higher inventory around the slower fall months. Let’s watch the spring market, which will be the bigger test.

I could write more, but let’s get visual instead.

DOWNLOAD 62 graphs HERE: Please download all graphs in this post and more here as a zip file. See my sharing policy for 5 ways to share (please don’t copy verbatim).

SACRAMENTO COUNTY (more graphs here):

SACRAMENTO REGION (more graphs here):

PLACER COUNTY (more graphs here):

NOTE: I cut out a few graphs and data this month. If you miss something, let me know.

DOWNLOAD 62 graphs HERE: Please download all graphs in this post and more here as a zip file. See my sharing policy for 5 ways to share (please don’t copy verbatim).

Questions: What are you seeing out there in the market? Is the top softening? What are buyers saying about interest rates? Anything I missed? I’d love to hear your take.

If you liked this post, subscribe by email (or RSS). Thanks for being here.

Fanny packs, pendings, and a slower market

By 12 Comments

I guess I never thought I’d talk about fanny packs on my blog, but here goes. This is either a new high or low depending on your perspective, but I want to share an important concept to consider – especially during a slower market. Then for anyone interested I have a big market update for Sacramento. Any thoughts?

Fanny pack analogy: Imagine spotting a guy wearing a fanny pack. You might think, “Sweet, I haven’t seen one since the early 90s.” The truth is if we only saw one dude sporting a pouch, we’d probably just think this person is trapped in the 80s and 90s (like Uncle Rico back in ’82). After all, one guy’s fashion statement doesn’t mean it’s a trend for everyone. But if we started seeing more and more people wearing fanny packs everywhere we went, then it’s probably a fashion trend. The same thing happens with pendings. If we only have one pending at a much higher level than anything else in the market area, it’s probably an outlier more than anything. It might be an isolated incident that’s totally disconnected from the market (like one guy wearing a fanny pack) rather than a real indicator of value (a trend). But if we saw a group of pendings shifting higher or lower, then that’s probably a trend.

The big point: Sometimes we get so distracted by the bling of one high listing or pending that we fail to see the bigger picture of value in a neighborhood. It’s like we develop tunnel vision and get locked into one outlier rather than looking at everything else that is similar AND trending lower. Sellers in particular struggle with this during the fall because they sometimes only see the highest prices from the spring rather than current listings and pendings that might be generating slightly lower prices because the market has softened. Or it’s easy to see that one overpriced listing down the street and expect to fetch a similar lofty price rather than recognizing that zero properties are getting into contract that high. Thus let’s be cautious not to stake all the weight of value on one “lone ranger” pending or listing while ignoring all other data. Otherwise it’s sort of like seeing one guy wearing a fanny pack and calling it a trend…

Disclaimer: This post was in no way meant to offend anyone who used to wear, currently wears, or will wear a fanny pack.  🙂

–——-——- Big monthly market update (it’s long on purpose) ———–——-

The market has continued to soften, though it’s not really all that soft. Inventory is up, price reductions have increased, sales volume has been dropping, it took three days longer to sell last month in the region, and price metrics are down about 1% from the height of summer. Overall the market is clearly slowing down for the season, though it’s not painfully dull like it was in 2013 or 2014 during the fall. This is a key to understand because when saying values are “softening” some interpret that to mean the market is really slow or crashing. But that’s not what I’m saying.

Big Point: We have a housing shortage, but that’s not a trump card to stop a slower seasonal trend.

Let’s get technical. Many price stats last month actually showed an increase in value by about 1%. What the? Does this mean the market increased? I thought you just told me the market is slowing? Let’s remember that sales from October really tell us more about properties that got into contract in August and September before they actually closed escrow in October. Thus that 1% uptick really happened in the market a couple of months ago rather than in October. In other words we’ll see the real trend of the market for October when the pendings from October close in November and December. This is so important because let’s not make a big deal about the market technically showing an increase because the uptick didn’t technically happen last month. Know what I’m saying? If we want to see the current market we have to look at the sales, but we cannot forget to give strong weight to the listings and pendings. Are properties taking longer to sell? Are there more listings hitting the market? Are properties starting to generate less offers or offers at lower prices? What are buyers, sellers, and the real estate community saying about the market?

A huge soft stat: Every year the median price and average sales price in Sacramento County tend to soften by about 5%. This doesn’t necessarily mean values decline by 5% in every neighborhood or price range, but it does mean we can expect price softening in most areas during the fall season.

By the way, here’s an article I wrote for Comstock’s magazine this month about some of the different layers of the Sacramento market right now.

I could go on, but let’s get visual.

DOWNLOAD 62 graphs HERE: Please download all graphs in this post and more here as a zip file (includes a stat sheet too). See my sharing policy for 5 ways to share (please don’t copy verbatim).

SACRAMENTO COUNTY (more graphs & stats here):

SACRAMENTO COUNTY STATS:

  1. The median price is currently $349,450. It’s up slightly from last month but down 1% from summer.
  2. The median price is 9.2% higher than the same time last year.
  3. Sales volume in October was 5.4% lower this year than 2016. There were 1456 single family detached sales last month.
  4. It took an average of 29 days to sell a home last month (one year ago it was taking 4 days longer).
  5. The median days on market last month was 15 days.
  6. It took 1 more day to sell in October compared to September (median days).
  7. FHA sales were 19.9% of all sales last month in the county.
  8. Only 0.7% of sales last month were bank-owned & 0.7% were short sales.
  9. The avg price per sq ft was about $221, which is about 1% lower than last month (9% higher than last year).
  10. The avg sales price increased about 1% last month and is currently $386,000. This is 9.4% higher than last year.
  11. Cash sales were 12.2% of all sales last month.

SACRAMENTO REGION (more graphs & stats here):

SACRAMENTO REGION STATS:

  1. The median price is $392,000. It increased about 2% last month, but it’s down 1% from summer.  
  2. The median price is 9.8% higher than the same time last year.
  3. Sales volume in October was nearly the same as October 2016. There were 2380 single family detached sales last month.
  4. It took an average of 34 days to sell a home last month (one year ago it was taking 3 days longer).
  5. The median days on market last month was 18 days, which means properties are selling really quickly.
  6. The median days on market increased by 3 days last month, which shows a slowing in the market.  
  7. FHA sales were 16.5% of all sales last month.
  8. Only 0.8% of sales last month were bank-owned & 0.8% were short sales.
  9. The avg price per sq ft was about $227, which is down slightly from last month (9% higher than last year).
  10. The avg sales price increased about 1% last month and down about 1.5% from summer (but up 9.4% higher than last year.
  11. Cash sales were 15% of all sales last month.

PLACER COUNTY (more graphs & stats here):

PLACER COUNTY STATS:

  1. The median price is currently $455,000 and increased about 1% last month.
  2. The median price is 3.8% higher than the same time last year.
  3. Sales volume in October was 10% higher than 2016. There were 533 single family detached sales.
  4. It took an average of 37 days to sell a home last month (one year ago it was taking 4 days longer).
  5. The median days on market last month was 22 days, which means properties are selling really quickly.
  6. The median days on market increased by 4 days last month, which shows a slowing in the market. 
  7. FHA sales were 9.5% of all sales.
  8. There were only 4 bank-owned sales last month and only 4 short sales.
  9. The avg price per sq ft was $232, which is slightly higher than last month (9.2% higher than last year).
  10. The avg sales price is currently $511,121. This is 6.4% higher than last year.
  11. Cash sales were 18% of all sales last month.

DOWNLOAD 62 graphs HERE: Please download all graphs in this post and more here as a zip file (includes a stat sheet too). See my sharing policy for 5 ways to share (please don’t copy verbatim).

Questions: On a serious note, did you wear a fanny pack back in the day? Anything else you’re seeing in the market? I’d love to hear your take.

If you liked this post, subscribe by email (or RSS). Thanks for being here.

A slowing market & value by Starbucks cups

By 8 Comments

Imagine not being able to see home prices. How would we measure value? In other words, could we determine higher values in one area compared to another based on things like school ratings, owner occupancy rates, or the income of residents? Let’s consider that, talk about the market in terms of Starbucks cups, and then dig deep into Sacramento trends for those interested. Any thoughts?

If we couldn’t see prices, what would be the best indicator of value?

1) Income of residents.
2) School ratings.
3) Percentage of owner occupied units.
4) Crime rates.
5) Length of grass.
6) Walking score.
7) Proximity to Downtown.
8) Proximity to coffee shops.
9) Number of cats in the neighborhood (thanks Gary).
10) What else?

The Takeaway: If we didn’t have access to prices in an area we could probably analyze some of the list above to get a sense of higher or lower values in certain areas. Ultimately we have to remember value is about the stuff behind the price, so it’s key to be in tune with what’s making value move in various places.

Here is a Twitter poll I ran:

Starbucks cups instead of price: Keeping with the theme, let’s talk about the market in terms of the cost of Starbucks cups (tall size) instead of price.

Real stats in the Sacramento region (but with coffee):

1) The median price softened by 2,512 cups of Starbucks coffee last month.
2) Since summer the median price has softened by 5,128 cups of coffee.
3) The median price will likely decline by 10,000 cups of coffee this fall.
4) The median price is up 15,384 coffee cups compared to last year.

Okay, don’t take me too seriously on this. But isn’t it interesting to think about value beyond just price? Next week: Avocado toast price metrics… (kidding).

I hope that was interesting. Anything to add?

–——-——- Big monthly market update (it’s long on purpose) ———–——-

We’re at that time of year. Sales volume has likely peaked for the season. The median price probably climaxed in the summer. Housing inventory is increasing, and each month it’s taking longer to sell in Sacramento. Overall the market has a slower feel compared to a few months ago, values have begun to soften in many areas, and even rents have been flat for a few months according to Yardi Matrix. We’re seeing a seasonal softening in county-wide stats (especially regional stats), but we’re also observing slowness in many neighborhoods as homes are tending to have less offers, less traffic, and even sell for slightly less than the highest prices from a few months back. News like this sometimes freaks people out because they think the market is tanking, but like clockwork the market almost always softens during the fall.

A huge stat to know: Every year the median price and average sales price in Sacramento County tend to soften by about 5%. This doesn’t necessarily mean values decline by 5% in every neighborhood or price range, but it does mean we can expect price softening in most areas during the fall season.

A word to sellers: Don’t be that stereotypical person who doesn’t listen to the market when it comes to price. Right now the market is slowing and the number of price reductions is higher than it’s been all year. As long as you’re priced reasonably you’re going to get offers, but be cautious not to price unrealistically high because you’re hearing the market is blazing “hot”.

I could go on, but let’s get visual.

DOWNLOAD 73 graphs HERE: Please download all graphs in this post and more here as a zip file (includes a stat sheet too). See my sharing policy for 5 ways to share (please don’t copy verbatim).

SACRAMENTO COUNTY (more graphs & stats here):

SACRAMENTO COUNTY STATS:

  1. The median price is currently $347,500 and dipped 0.1% last month.
  2. The median price is 9.6% higher than the same time last year.
  3. Sales volume in September was 6.8% lower this year than 2016. There were 1499 single family detached sales last month.
  4. It took an average of 26 days to sell a home last month (one year ago it was taking 4 days longer).
  5. The median days on market last month was 14 days.
  6. It took 2 more days to sell in September compared to August (median days).
  7. FHA sales were 19.4% of all sales last month in the county.
  8. Only 1% of sales last month were bank-owned & 1.1% were short sales.
  9. The avg price per sq ft was about $223, which is slightly higher than last month (11% higher than last year).
  10. The avg sales price increased about 1.3% last month and is currently $384,000. This is 10.9% higher than last year.
  11. Cash sales were 13% of all sales last month.

SACRAMENTO REGION (more graphs & stats here):

SACRAMENTO REGION STATS:

  1. The median price is $385,000 and declined about 1% last month.
  2. The median price is 8.4% higher than the same time last year.
  3. Sales volume in September was 3.6% lower this year than 2016. There were 2422 single family detached sales last month.
  4. It took an average of 31 days to sell a home last month (one year ago it was taking 4 days longer).
  5. The median days on market last month was 15 days, which means properties are selling really quickly.
  6. The median days on market increased by 2 days last month, which helps shows a slowing in the market.  
  7. FHA sales were 16.1% of all sales last month.
  8. Only 1.1% of sales last month were bank-owned & 0.8% were short sales.
  9. The avg price per sq ft was about $228, which increased about 1% last month (10% higher than last year).
  10. The avg sales price declined about 1% last month and is currently $425,516. This is 8.3% higher than last year.
  11. Cash sales were 14.9% of all sales last month.

PLACER COUNTY (more graphs & stats here):

PLACER COUNTY STATS:

  1. The median price is currently $450,000 and declined about 3% last month.
  2. The median price is 4% higher than the same time last year.
  3. Sales volume in September was 1.3% less this year than 2016. There were 524 single family detached sales.
  4. It took an average of 34 days to sell a home last month (one year ago it was taking 7 days longer).
  5. The median days on market last month was 18 days, which means properties are selling really quickly.
  6. The median days on market increased by 3 days last month, which helps shows a slowing in the market. 
  7. FHA sales were 12.9% of all sales.
  8. There were only 3 bank-owned sales last month and only 2 short sales.
  9. The avg price per sq ft was $231, which is slightly higher than last month (9.1% higher than last year).
  10. The avg sales price decreased about 3.5% last month and is currently $490,615. This is 1.6% higher than last year.
  11. Cash sales were 17.1% of all sales last month.

DOWNLOAD 73 graphs HERE: Please download all graphs in this post and more here as a zip file (includes a stat sheet too). See my sharing policy for 5 ways to share (please don’t copy verbatim).

Questions: Besides price, what do you think the strongest indicator of value is for a neighborhood? Anything else you’re seeing in the market? Should we start a Starbucks Cups Price Index maybe? I’d love to hear your take.

If you liked this post, subscribe by email (or RSS). Thanks for being here.