Sacramento Appraisal Blog | Real Estate Appraiser

Real estate appraisals for divorce, estate settlement, loans, property tax appeal, pre-listing and more. We cover Sacramento, Placer and Yolo County. We're professional, courteous and timely.

El Dorado Hills

Stale real estate headlines & buyers flocking to El Dorado County

By 8 Comments

Real estate headlines can get stale quickly, so we have to be really aware of what we’re saying. Is it still even true? Here’s an example of what I mean.

Headlines in recent years: Rising fire insurance rates in California are causing buyers to pull back from more rural areas.

New stats that change the narrative: In El Dorado County this past year we actually saw a larger increase of sales volume WITHIN areas that have higher fire insurance. Take a look at this visual. Typically El Dorado Hills & Cameron Park don’t have fire insurance issues whereas the rest of El Dorado County does (generally speaking). In short, volume in “fire areas” grew more than areas without issues.

Off the charts: Here is a visual to show how off the charts sales volume has been in El Dorado County. There was an initial COVID dip early in the year and then a massive increase WAY beyond normal.

QUICK TAKEAWAYS:

1) The market is always changing, so we need to be sure our narrative is informed by actual data instead of headlines from last year.

2) Uncertainty about fire insurance rates clearly didn’t hold back buyers this year in El Dorado County. Part of this could stem from rates regulating and buyers getting used to higher rates, but there is no mistaking El Dorado County had enormous pandemic migration. Thus incoming buyers simply cared way more about having land and space than fire insurance rates.

3) I’ve only run stats for El Dorado County, so I’d be careful about saying fire insurance is no biggie throughout California. Moreover, this trend could change in coming years. It’s actually very difficult to parse fire stats for Placer County. If anyone has ideas for how to do that I’m open ears. I just haven’t found a way yet.

VIDEO MARKET UPDATE:

Yesterday I did a big market update at Joel Wright’s Residential Roundup event. This is 38 minutes. Enjoy if you wish or skip to the last slide with closing thoughts to focus business in 2021. Watch below (or here).

PRESENTATION TODAY: I’m speaking at a Placer County Women’s Council of Realtors event from 10-11:30am. I’ll have one hour to unpack the market and I have some fresh Placer and El Dorado stats too. Sign up here.

Thanks for being here.

Questions: What are you seeing in El Dorado County or other areas? What are you hearing about fire insurance? I’d love to hear your take.

If you liked this post, subscribe by email (or RSS). Thanks for being here.

Appraisal waivers & the foreclosure wave

By 12 Comments

I have two things on my mind today. Yesterday I had a conversation about appraisal waivers and “hybrid” appraisals, so I wanted to share my take. Then I have some new graphs to help tell the story of the foreclosure crisis.

APPRAISAL WAIVERS & “HYBRID” APPRAISALS:

Here’s a Q&A with with Scott Short on appraisal waivers and “hybrid” appraisals. I get things changing for appraisers in light of big data, but diminishing the role appraisers play seems like a bad idea for the housing market. Watch here. If you want to just hear the “hybrid” part, it’s at 7:12.

By the way, a local appraiser named Barry Cleverdon had an accident a few weeks ago and is currently in a coma. Here is Barry’s GoFundMe.

THE FORECLOSURE CRISIS:

1) Healing: The foreclosure rate in the United States is way down. I would guess most markets have essentially healed. In Sacramento County ten years ago 84% of sales were distressed and now that number is less than 2% when considering both short sales and bank-owned sales (REOs).

2) Not the same in every neighborhood: When it comes to distressed sales, some areas and price ranges did better than others as you can see below. This reminds us the market doesn’t experience the same exact trend everywhere.

3) The power of equity: Areas with more equity and higher prices tended to fare better with the number of distressed sales. I know that’s what we’d expect to see, but it’s interesting to actually see it. It’s amazing how equity (and probably better jobs) can create opportunity and even help people weather a storm.

4) The promise of a new wave: Many have promised a new wave of foreclosures, but we just haven’t seen it. I hear things like, “Dude, there are so many Notice of Defaults right now.” That may be true, but not all of these NODs end up hitting the market. Or if they do go into foreclosure they may likely be sold on the court steps before MLS.

Two weeks ago I asked friends on LinkedIn which areas they wanted to see, and that’s how this post was born. I didn’t get to everywhere, but I got to most areas.

MAKE GRAPHS LIKE THIS: If you want to know how to make a graph like this, here’s a tutorial for how to put a few different layers of data on one graph.

BLOG BASH: Just a reminder my wife and I are hosting a party at Yolo Brewing on Saturday March 2nd. It’s an excuse to get together and you’re invited. It’s okay if we’ve never met too. I’ll be buying the first 100 beers. Details here.

Questions: What do you think of appraisal waivers and “hybrid” appraisals? What stands out to you most in the images above?

If you liked this post, subscribe by email (or RSS). Thanks for being here.

Being neutral, price per square foot, and the Governor’s new digs

By 35 Comments

I have a few things on my mind. Let’s talk about me being asked to recruit for a brokerage (really), price per sq ft, and the Governor’s new digs.

1) WHY I SAID “NO”:

A brokerage recently asked me if I would help them recruit agents. The idea was I could use my influence to attract agents to a certain brand and then get a commission for each person I recruited.

I said NO, and my answer will always be NO. I probably don’t even need to mention this, but I want to communicate clearly. As an appraiser I won’t take sides. I’m neutral in my work, but my independence also extends in the way I interact with the real estate community. This is why you’ll see me speaking in many different places and real estate offices. I’m here to educate, not advocate. The truth is if I said yes I would’ve instantly destroyed my credibility.

2) PRICE PER SQ FT:

Here’s a look at price per sq ft trends in a few local areas. I plan to share more graphs like this throughout the year if people like them. Does anyone want to see a video tutorial for how to make these? Let me know. What do you see?

Two Takeaways:

1) RANGE: There’s always a price per sq ft range, which means there’s never just one price per sq ft figure that applies to every property in a neighborhood. Sellers often want to hijack a price per sq ft figure from a sale down the street, but that’s one of the quickest ways to overprice. My advice? Pay attention to price per sq ft, but most of all ask yourself what the comps are selling for. That’s exactly what appraisers are going to do.

2) OUTLIERS: There are clear outliers. As an FYI, usually the highest price per sq ft figures end up representing the smallest-sized homes or over-the-top unique properties.

3) THE GOVERNOR’S NEW DIGS: 

Gavin Newsom is the new governor of California and he just bought a $3.7M house in Fair Oaks. This price point isn’t much in many areas of the country, but it’s actually the fifth highest residential sale ever in Sacramento County. This home is said to have over 12,000 sq ft and it’s located on 8 acres. It’s near the American River, but not on the river. Now two of the top five sales in the county have a connection to a governor (the other was the mansion Ronald Reagan started to build in Carmichael in the 1970s).

Here’s a picture I took of the front gate this week, and here’s a video from a previous listing if you wish to see the home. Not too shabby, right?

Value thought: In the future we’ll have to consider whether there will be a price premium or not for this home because a governor owned the property.

CLASS I’M TEACHING: I’m teaching my favorite class at SAR called How to Think Like an Appraiser on January 31st from 9-12pm. We’ll dig deep into comps and adjustments (and have some fun). I’d love to have you come out.

I hope this was helpful or interesting.

Questions: Would you pay more if a governor previously owned the home? What do you think of my recruiting story? I’d love to hear your take.

If you liked this post, subscribe by email (or RSS). Thanks for being here.

A Story of Property Value from the Sales History in Tax Records: El Dorado Hills, CA

By 2 Comments

The real estate market has been an interesting ride over the past years in the Greater Sacramento Area, and the ups and downs of the market tend to show up when viewing a property’s sales history in Tax Records. I’m always curious to have a look at what houses sold for in 2005 or 2007 and what they are selling for now. I came across a house in the Serrano area of El Dorado Hills and I found the sales history below to tell a story about the market. This story could have come from mostly any area of the Sacramento Region really because in most cases there is a huge difference between property valuess in 2005 and 2010.

8/25/2005  $916,500 (original sale from builder)

6/30/2008  $735,000 (sale from original owner to new owner – not a short sale because the original owner put down $200,000+ on the original purchase).

2/04/2009  $429,500 (transfer – not a public sale – deed in lieu of foreclosure. We have seen banks exercise this option quite a bit so a property technically does not go into foreclosure). 

5/27/2010  $551,000 (resale on the open market).

What do you think?